The debate continues

Knight School

Knights at Carlisle Castle;
Requests for mercy had to be granted.

Lincolnshire Police are putting unruly youngsters through their paces on an eight-week 'knight school', to teach them some of the ways of medieval knights. The scheme has been hailed a success in improving behaviour, so what kind of lessons could knights teach youngsters today?

How much is this part of our debate ?

Knights of old were either virtuous and honest men who lived according to a code of chivalry, or a bunch of marauding looters who were lucky to get a good write up in the history books.

Whatever the reality, are there some values associated with chivalry which could be applied today? We canvassed opinion among medieval experts.

10 lessons from the Medieval Knights.

• 1. Generosity was important. Even though knights were of a certain status in society, with servants and followers, they were expected to be generous in handing out rewards. For example, in battle a knight may take quite a lot of booty but would be expected to distribute that to followers in recognition of their service to him.
  Lesson for children today - Share.



• 2. Mercy is one of the key concepts of chivalry. Fighting with another knight, if one offers defeat then the other should exercise mercy and be gracious in victory. The whole concept of ransoming was based on this. A knight would honour and respect a fellow knight when fighting him or when holding him captive.
  Lesson for today - If you get in a tussle and win, go easy on the other kid.
  
• 3. Loyalty to your Sovereign and those in authority is absolutely crucial.
  Lesson for today - abide by the rules and recognise the law"
  
• 4. Exercise power responsibly. They didn't get rid of violence but they tried to limit it to justified causes.
  Lesson for children today - Just because you're the biggest in the class, don't throw your weight around.
  
• 5. Protect the weak. There's also a sense that the strong should protect the weak who are unable to look after themselves.
  Lesson for today - Stand up to bullies and gangs who pick on other children.
  
• 6. Justice. Seek always the path of "right", unencumbered by bias or personal interest. Recognize that the sword of justice can be a terrible thing, so it must be tempered by humanity and mercy.
  Less for today - Fight for what's right.
  
• 7. Humility. Value first the contributions of others; do not boast of your own accomplishments, let others do this for you. Tell the deeds of others before your own, according them the renown rightfully earned through virtuous deeds.
  Lesson for today - Give credit to your pals.
  
• 8. Show Respect for all other religions.
  Lesson for today - Never quarrel over faiths
  
• 9. Only the Foolhardy brandish weapons.
  Lesson for today - Don't carry knives.
  
• 10. Courtly love, Behave kindly and with respect towards all members of the opposite sex.
  Lesson for today - ladies must never be hurt or harmed in anyway .

(1, 2, 3: Dr Gwilym Dodd, Nottingham University. 4, 5, 8, 9, 10: Dr Nick Higham, University of Manchester, 6,7: Brian Price, editor of Knighthood, Chivalry and Tournaments)

Has no one heard of The Order of DeMolay

* * * * *